Tuesday, 1 August 2017

Hell on Earth - Passchendaele Centenary 1917 - 2017. By Griselda Heppel

What’s it like to be at the heart of Hell? 

Very hot, in most people’s minds. Unbearably hot. The hottest and fieriest part of a mythical world in which the wicked are burnt forever in punishment for their misdeeds.


Dante Alighieri
Well, if you thought that, you’d be wrong, according to Dante Alighieri, whose first part of The Divine Comedy, The Inferno, is an imaginary descent through all the nine circles of Hell. Not about the wicked being punished - that’s non-negotiable - nor about the parts of Hell that do rage with fire (hence the modern use of Inferno to describe such terrible disasters as Grenfell Tower); but about the centre of Hell itself, the lowest circle in which the wickedest souls of all are punished. They are the traitors: betrayers of family, country, guests, benefactors and finally, God himself. There is no heat of passion in their crimes, only cold, ruthless calculation; their punishment is to be frozen forever in a vast, desolate, treeless plain, an outside manifestation of the ice in their own hearts. 

Hell freezing over for Dante and Virgil (Gustav Dore)
The depiction of Dante and Virgil stumbling among these immobile figures, trying not to kick at the heads just poking above ground, in the teeth of a bitter wind, is one of the most chilling episodes of the whole Inferno. Not only that: the Hell created here has an immediacy of detail that brings it horribly close to human experience. Take away the moral judgement aspect, pockmark the plain with craters and jab it with barbed wire fences, scatter millions of cartridge cases and pieces of shrapnel, add bursts of machine gun and shellfire, relieve the darkness sporadically with flares and waterlog the ground with steady, unceasing rain - and you have Siegfried Sassoon’s famous line: I died in Hell - (They called it Passchendaele). 

Passchendaele - Hell on earth.

This is why, when updating Dante’s Hell for my children’s version of his story, Ante’s Inferno, I could think of no better way to try to match the horror of his ninth circle than to follow Sassoon’s lead. 
   An accident at school sends 12 year-old Ante (Antonia) on a journey through the Underworld, accompanied by her worst enemy, Florence, and Gil, a boy who died 100 years before the story begins, on the eve of the First World War. At first, the three of them have to deal merely (!) with creatures and monsters from classical legend, such as Cerberus, Charon, harpies and the minotaur.
Charon ferries Dante and Vergil across the Styx. (Gustav Dore)
                                                       It’s lower down that man-made instruments of destruction come into their own, culminating in the bottom of Hell consisting of a recreation of the battle of Passchendaele, arguably the most terrible of the whole war. From its beginning on 31 July until the capture of Passchendaele ridge by the Canadian Corps on 10 November, 1917, the casualties on both sides came to well over half a million: shot, blown up, gassed and even drowned, as vast areas of the ground had been churned into liquid mud many feet deep. Siegfried Sassoon wasn’t wrong. Even in light of so many other appalling WW1 battles, Passchendaele stands out.

Australian troops at Passchendaele. (photo courtesy of IWM)

This year marks 100 years since the battle took place, an anniversary I’ll be bringing out on a number of school visits I have booked around Remembrance Day in November (I have room for more, any Year 5 - 8 teachers out there!). In honour of the Centenary, Ante’s Inferno has undergone a special reprint, the jacket updated by the addition of this haunting photograph from the Imperial War Museum.

Looking at that flat, grey, desolate wasteland of mud and water, spiked with bare tree trunks where once a forest had been, 
I think Dante would have understood. 


Always assuming he’d forgive my cheek in reimagining his masterpiece in the first place…


Find out more about Griselda Heppel here:



and her children's books:

Ante's Inferno 

 and 

The Tragickall History of Henry Fowst



7 comments:

Wendy Jones said...

Love this. Thanks. The book sounds right up my street.

sandra horn said...

I am trying to put my wyebrows down where they belong after reading this! What power! Thank you, Griselda!

griseldaheppel said...

Thank you both so much! I'm thrilled Ante's Inferno has made such an impression on you.

Dennis Hamley said...

That's a great post, Griselda. Passchendaele was worse even than the Somme. There's something horribly prescient about the very name.And Ante's Inferno is such a wonderful book.

Helen Wood said...

I read this two years ago with a year 6 group. When they arrived in Hell with the protagonists they were captivated by the smooth talking Devil, and the portrayal of Hell as a WW1battlefield generated discussion after discussion. To date, it has been my all time favourite guided reading book. Thank you Griselda.

Fran B said...

This is a new one on me. It sounds amazing.

griseldaheppel said...

Catching up belatedly on these lovely comments, thank you all! Helen, what you say about your Form 6 reading Ante's Inferno is the most thrilling of all. Capturing children's interest in a story while introducing them to deeper, even painful adult themes (such as war and destruction) in a way they can handle is exactly what I wanted to do (with some lighter moments on the way!). I loved visiting them and talking about Dante, Seven Deadly Sins etc as well as the WW1 theme.
I agree, Dennis, the name Passchendaele with its ring of Christ's Passion (as in St Matthew Passion) is almost a tragic example of nominative determinism (if that's the right term).